Book Review: Witch Upon a Star (Witch Way Librarian Mysteries, #4) by Jenn McKinlay
There’s something irresistibly enchanting about a cozy mystery that pairs the arcane with the ordinary, and Witch Upon a Star strikes that delightful balance beautifully. Jenn McKinlay has crafted a story that pulled me in with its witty humor, heartfelt themes, and the endearing chaos of familial love, all wrapped around a curious mystery that had me guessing until the very end.
Set in the charming town of Wilfred, this fourth installment in the Witch Way Librarian Mysteries series centers around Josie, who finds herself juggling her protective instincts for her sister Jean and the ominous presence of two dead bodies that disrupt the tranquil retreat. From the start, I was captivated by Josie’s dynamic relationship with her family. Her mother’s overbearing nature reminded me of my own, and I could fully relate to the struggle of wanting to be supportive while also needing to assert one’s independence. Josie’s internal conflict about Jean being naïve yet inherently wise was particularly poignant, showcasing the complexity of sisterhood.
The plot thickens swiftly with the dual murders: Marcia at the retreat center and Anders at the reopened café. McKinlay deftly weaves in threads of suspicion and intrigue, keeping readers riveted. I loved how the story unfolded; the pacing felt just right, balancing moments of tension with lighter, humorous exchanges among the lively Wilfredians. Each character had distinct quirks that made them memorable, particularly the enigmatic Cookie Masterston—part life coach, part cult leader in the eyes of some. Her “Ready, Set, Go!” workshops felt both ridiculous and strangely fitting, mirroring the absurdities we sometimes chase in life.
McKinlay’s writing style shines in its ability to paint vivid imagery while invoking a cozy, conversational tone. I found myself chuckling at Josie’s witty observations and the quirky antics of the townsfolk. The interplay between characters felt genuinely warm and relatable, especially the sisterly banter that highlighted the unconditional love woven through their conflicts.
One of my favorite moments was Josie’s realization of her unique powers as a librarian, almost like a magical skill of knowing what folks need before they even ask. It brought a smile to my face and made me reflect on the sometimes unnoticed magic we bring to our own daily lives.
As for the mysteries themselves, McKinlay kept me on my toes. Each twist invited me to reconsider my suspicions, culminating in satisfying reveals that, while perhaps not shocking, left me content with how each character’s arc resolved. I appreciated the exploration of trust and the questions surrounding personal motivations—each character felt fleshed out, with commendable depth.
Witch Upon a Star is perfect for cozy mystery lovers and fans of strong, character-driven narratives. If you’re someone who enjoys a good blend of humor, heart, and a sprinkle of magic with your whodunits, this book will undoubtedly charm your socks off! As I closed the final pages, I found myself yearning to dive into the next book to see how Josie’s relationship with Sam evolves and what further adventures await in Wilfred.
In short, this story was not just about solving a mystery; it was a celebration of family, the power of support, and the quirky town that felt like home. That’s the kind of magic that stays with you long after you’ve turned the last page.
Discover more about Witch Upon a Star (Witch Way Librarian Mysteries, #4) on GoodReads >>